Hutton (Stark) Cemetery - Pleasant Hill Township

Divider Line
The Hutton Cemetery is also known as Hutton-Starks or Hutton Hill Cemetery.
It is located on the bluff above the Pleasant Hill &
Nebo Road (County Road 10) and overlooks Nebo.
It is between the turn off for Rd. 2925 and Rd. 3005E.
There is a small gravel lane up the hill that is posted with a "No Trespassing" sign.
It has been abandoned and is not maintained.
Contributed by Rosemary Reeves
Kathy Robinson updated this cemetery 23 Feb 2012
Divider Line
NAMEBIRTHDEATHSPOUSEPARENTS
ALLISON, Delilah (Applegate) 31 Nov 1807 19 Mar 1872 John W. Combs
Nathan Allison
Hezekiah and Susan (Brittain) Applegate
APPLEGATE, Samuel 05 Feb 1793 12 Sep 1870 Sarah Stark In memory of Elder Samuel Applegate, ordained minister in Baptist Church A. D. 1825
APPLEGATE, Sarah (Stark) 1780 22 Aug 1846 Samuel Applegate
BARNEY, Lidia 09 Sep 1799 14 Apr 1860 Nichols B. Barney (Apparantly not found by Kathy Robinson)
BUCHANAN, George Washington 13 Sep 1846 26 Jan 1847 Valentine A. and Nancy Emeline (Hamilton) Buchanan
BUCHANAN, Nancy Emeline (Hamilton) 11 Mar 1827 21 Sep 1897 Valentine Armstead Buchanan John Riley and Mary (Rossen) Hamilton
BUCHANAN, Valentine Armstead 28 Dec 1810 22 Jan 1874 Nancy Emeline Hamilton John Buchanan and Mary Rosson
CANNON, N.C. N. E. Found in Cemetery Book
CANNON, Infant Son 26 Jul 1859 26 Jul 1859 Found in Cemetery Book
D. E. & A. E. M. Cannon
CANNON, Nancy K. 1851 16 Sep 1854 William Duncan Cannon and Sarah Serena Hamilton
COMBS, Little H. 17 Nov 1834 18 Apr 1864 John & Delilah (Applegate) Combs
GUSTON, Emma R. 28 Jan 1881 25 Jul 1883 John William & Mary C/E. Waid Davey Guston
GUSTON, Ida May 01 Jun 1879 23 Jul 1883 J. W. and M. E. Gustin
HAMILTON, John H. 21 Apr 1804 04 Mar 1855 Keziah B. Applegate
HAMILTON, Keziah B. (Applegate) 18 Feb 1806 05 Oct 1880 John H. Hamilton
3 Jun 1826 Rhea Co TN
Samuel and Sarah (Stark) Applegate
HOLFORD, Thomas Joseph Marion 1y 3m 20d 25 Jul 1872 J. R. & S. P. Holford
with the Starks family
HUTTON, Mary Ann (Haitt) 07 Apr 1823 08 Sep 1913 William C. Hutton
21 Feb 1841 Franklin Co MO
HUTTON, William C. 12 Jul 1819 14 Nov 1889 Mary Ann Hiatt
PETTY, Daughter 19 Aug 1872 20 Aug 1872 Isaac Fisher and Elizabeth Laura (Fowler) Petty
REYNOLDS, Robert 01 Apr 1822 26 Dec 1859 Broken pieces found by Mati Stark and posted on Find-A-Grave 4/16/2016
RICHEY, Joseph George 07 Apr 1812 25 Feb 1854 Elizabeth A. Stark
17 Aug 1835 Scott Co IN
John and Sichy (Collings) Richy
SHAW, Anguish 04 Mar 1842 06 Feb 1891 Rosa A. Franklin Geo. Washington and Mary (McCullock) Shaw
SHAW, George Washington 16 Jul 1839 22 Apr 1880 Mary Jane Pennington George Washington Shaw Sr. & Mary McCullock
SHAW, 4 Infant Sons Anguish & Rose A. (Franklin) Shaw
SHAW, Mary Jane (Pennington) 1839 1914 George Washington Shaw
SHAW, Rose A. (Franklin) 1852 Anguish Shaw Richard J. and Mary M. (Gilkey) Franklin
STARK, Abraham K. 28 Apr 1852 26 May 1853 John P. & Elizabeth (Applegate) Stark
STARK, Christopher 11 Jun 1802 24 Oct 1862 James Vineyard and Rebecca (Pound) Stark
STARK, Elizabeth P. (Applegate) 22 May 1816 22 Mar 1863 John P. Stark Samuel and Sarah (Stark) Applegate
STARK, Florence 06 Jan 1906 12 Feb 1907 William C. and Laura (Ward) Stark
STARK, Infant Daughter 26 Jul 1857 13 Aug 1857 John P. and Elizabeth (Applegate) Stark
STARK, James Vineyard 10 May 1773 19 Oct 1853 Rebecca Pound
STARK, John Pound 06 Nov 1806 13 Aug 1873 Elizabeth P. Applegate
Mary "Polly" Craigmiles
James Vineyard and Rebecca (Pound)Stark
STARK, John Squire 20 Jun 1844 09 Sep 1901 Louisa Jane Hamner John Pound and Elizabeth (Applegate) Stark
STARK, Laura R. E. 10 Sep 1869 20 Oct 1876 John Pound & Nancy Mary (Cannon) Stark
STARK, Louisa Jane (Hamner) 07 Mar 1847 10 Apr 1931 John Squire Stark John Nelson and Harriet (Wynne) Hamner
STARK, Peter C. 1y5m 27d 19 Oct 1857 John Pound & Elizabeth Stark
Listed on Cemetery List only
STARK, William A. 1857 1860 John Henry and Martha Elizabeth (Hamilton) Stark
STEVENS, Edna Elizabeth (Smith) 15 Jan 1855 11 Feb 1901 John Wesley Stevens
TOLL, Infant Son 17 Feb 1859 17 Feb 1859 J. L. & M. Toll
On cemetery listing only
TOLL, Maria 15 Mar 1860 17 Feb 1861 J. L. & M. Toll
On cemetery listing only
WALSTON, Hattie Elizabeth (Stark) 01 Mar 1867 09 Dec 1900 James Perry Walston John Squire and Louisa Jane (Hamner) Stark
WILSON, Eliza Jane 30 Mar 1867 30 Aug 1891 William & Nancy Wilson
WINDMILLER, Olaf L. Feb 1882 15 Aug 1882 Jacob & Mary (Stone) Windmiller
WINDMILLER, Peter 07 Apr 1816 23 Jan 1879 Sevelia Applegate Margaretha Barbara (Schock) Windmiller
WINDMILLER, Peter N. 11 Dec 1858 17 Dec 1872 Peter and Sevelia (Applegate) Windmiller
WINDMILLER, Sevelia (Applegate) 1824 31 Jan 1881 Peter Windmiller Samuel and Sarah (Stark) Applegate
YOCUM, Jane 1821 14 Oct 1869 S. Yocum
YOCUM, Walter 25 Aug 1870 31 Aug 1871 William Samuel & Sarah Catheerine (Windmiller) Yocum
ZUMWALT, Elizabeth (Kistler) 1780 19 Oct 1845 Henry Miller Zumwalt No Headstone Found
ZUMWALT, Henry Miller 1780 16 Aug 1845 Jacob and Catherine (Miller) Zumwalt