Stotlar-Herrin Cemetery

This is a pioneer cemetery in Herrin were most of the earliest settlers are buried. Although it is well maintained, the older stones are in poor shape. Many of the older stones have broken and where place flat on the ground in concrete. While this keeps the stone in place with the grave, it causes the stone to be weathered more so most of these markers are unreadable.

I visited the cemetery 27 May 1999


Under a cedar tree there are 8 white marble stones, 6 of these have nothing on them and appear to me to have been footstones. 2 have writing but are broken and unreadable. There is one sandstone marker in the Herrin section

Broken stones 2

Unreadable stones 8

Unreadable stones in the Stotlar section 3

white broken stone died age 2 years

infant marker, This is facing a big tree, all I could see was what looks like c/o JE & CH Herrin

Sandstone marker in Herrin section with MH, no dates.

Broken stone which says Sterns, poss part of BK's marker.

Broken stone which says Herrin died age 25

White marker in the Stotlar section, with just CS, no dates.

Robert, unable to read but looks like s/o NA Roman, dates are gone.

Stone next to Elizabeth Dillard, name unreadable died 1865.

Stone next to Rebecca Farmer, name is gone died 13 Feb 1873 1y 10m 12d

Broken sandstone under the tree, M------- of William B Sanders 47y -- 22d, dates are gone.

Believed to be buried here but no stones found are Glatha Aterberry; Harriet and WL Henderson; Alfred J, Charles O and Narcissa Herrin; William J Pope and Isaac Southerland.

Aterberry William 13 Dec 1833 16 Jun 1863 25y Co D 128th IL
  Benjamin J   No dates* Pvt CWCo D 128th IL
Bandy William   02 Mar 1854 27 yrs
Bane? Alvis M   05 Feb 1902 1y 2d s/o CR & Willie
Berry Armilla   22 Oct 1900 1y 2m 29d d/o HA & Clare
Bradley Carrie 1852 1889  
  Ellenor   16 Mar 1851 22y 1m 29d w/o Newton
  Newton 02 M-- 1821 -- -- 1872  
Bruce Carl 01 Apr 1900 22 Jun 1996 m 19 Jun 1927 SFC WWI
  Julia 04 Jan 1903   w/o Carl
Caplinger Julia A 02 Jun 1831 26 Jan 1904 (nee Spiller)
Carver Elizabeth 28 Feb 1836 08 Aug 1878  
  John L 28 Feb 1832 28 Nov 1867  
Cox George 10 Nov 1809 20 Feb 1879  
  John 21 Nov 1841 18 Mar 1864* Pvt Co G 9th IL Inf s/o George
  Sarah Jane 27 Dec 1882 18 Jan 1911  
Dillard Elizabeth   07 Jan 1869 w/o John K or R
  Josiah C 14 Oct 1779 15 Aug 1865  
  Lydia   22 Dec 1862 w/o JJ
  William P 1816 1856 (broken)
Farmer Rebecca   23 May 18-- 27y w/o Q
Fry Oscar A 08 Jan 1887 27 Nov 1888 s/o John P & Anna
  William H 22 Oct 1888 29 Nov 1888 s/o John P & Anna
Gray Malinda   16 Jan 1870 w/o DeWitt
Harrison Carl 21 Jul 1893 20 Apr 1919 s/o GH & Laura
  David Rufus 15 Oct 1835 08 May 1911  
  Delilah P   28 Mar 1899 34y 1m 26d w/o George H
  Elizabeth   10 Mar 1899 59y 11m 12d w/o DR
  Fred G 31 Jul 1899 16 Jan 1972 s/o GH & Laura
  George H 14 Dec 1961 24 Jul 1950 s/o DR
  John Alden 15 Apr 1904 03 May 1983 US Navy
  Julia A   09 Jul 1874 37y 8m 22d w/o DR
  Laura 01 Jan 1871 31 Mar 1890 w/o George H
  Laurence 10 Nov 1895 12 Jul 1916 s/o GH & Laura
Henderson Elizabeth   06 Jan 1875 35y
  James C   22 May 1874 43y 11m 22d
  Will C     (Unable to read dates)
Herrin Infant 30 Jan 1903 30 Jan 1903 s/o JS & LC
  Alice Parvin 12 Jan 1907 28 Jul 1977  
  Andrew Jackson 18 Feb 1817 06 Jul 1901 obit (not found is this Alfred J)
  Bertie 1884 1908 w/o fred
  David 20 Mar 1852 15 Nov 1917 s/o AJ
  David 15 Aug 1793 01 Feb 1870 Sgt War of 1812
  Ephraim 18 Oct1843 05 Jan 1918* obit Pvt CW Co G 9th IL Inf s/o AJ
  Fatimma 1848 1939  
  Fred 1879 1961  
  Eva 12 Nov 1854 16 Feb 1930 w/o David
  George   06 Apr 1868 s/o J
  Guy     (Unable to read dates)
  James   16 Oct 1881 36y 3m 6d
  John D 1849 1876 (Mason)
  Josephine 1850 1939 w/o John D
  Malinda Mar 1822 Apr 1823 1y 1m 22d d/o David & Sarah
  Oliver   12 Jan 1860  
  Paul D 20 Apr 1875 06 Sep 1936  
  Rebecca   09 Jun 1891 (Might be 1881)
  Roy C   10 May 1898 12y 9m 8d s/o CO & Lucy
  Rosa E   26 Mar 1884 1m 19d d/o C & L
  Ruby 20 Nov 1877 11 Jul 1922 w/o Paul (nee Stotlar)
  Sarah 08 Nov 1791 31 Jul 1874 w/o David
Herring Isaac 1768 1843 (New stone 1st Settler)
  Isaac   29 Jun 1843 77 Yrs (Original stone)
  Unity 1770 1846 w/o Isaac
Holman Hosea 1872 1895 s/o J & M
Livesay Grace 31 Oct 1871 29 Jun 1901 (nee Herrin)
Mart       (Unable to read)
McNeill Olive 24 Aug 1846 07 Jul 1874 w/o George M nee Herrin
Morris Harry   1860  
  L   22 Nov 1852  
Newton Rebecca 1851 1891 w/o WT
Parsons Elizabeth   17 May 1897 78y 5m 5d w/o Samuel
  Elizabeth I 1853 1932 w/o Terry
  Kimberly J   29 Jul 1880 63y 3m 18d
  Narcissa   12 Jan 1902 73y 8m 21d w/o KJ
  Terry 1861 1949  
Reed Karl   1896 (unreadable)
Roberts Annie   24 Apr 1901 59y 5m 25d w/o George W (nee Herrin)
  George Edgar   13/18 --- 1881 22y 11m 16d
  George W 26 Mar 1838 no death date  
  Lisa   06 Dec 1899 27y --m 3d d/o G & --
Spence Margaret J   1869 w/o WH (dates under ground)
Spiller Clarence 1870 1873 s/o WE & C
  Jane   01 Feb 1845 25y w/o Jesse
Sterns B K   14 Aug ----  
  Ellen   1880 59y
  James W   17 Nov 1871 6m 6d
Stotlar (child)   ?? C/o James & C 14y 11m 29d
  infant no dates    
  Alexander M 1799 1852  
  Bennett H 1871 1884* Pvt CW Co G 9th IL Inf
  Caroline 1885 1887 d/o J & C
  Casander 17 Feb 1830 15 Nov 1886 w/o James
  Delilah E   28 Mar 1870 19y 1-m 1d w/o Allen
  Elizabeth 1817 17 May 1897 78y 5m 5d w/o Samuel (nee Parsons)
  Emily C 1857 1932 w/o Hiram M
  GA   16 Nov 1886 56y 3m 28d w/o James (nee Sanders)
  Hiram M 1855 1933  
  James 13 Jan 1830 02 Sep 1909 s/o Alexander
  James A no dates   (Infant)
  Leroy A 19 Mar 1884 08 Apr 1905  
  Louis Edwin 07 Jul 1894 08 May 1975 Cpl WWI
  Louisa 15 Oct 1848 16 Feb 1901 w/o Thomas (nee Cox)
  Samuel 1814 27 Jul 1876 62y 3m 15d
  Sarah 29 Mar 1853 28 May 1923 w/o William N (nee Cox)
  Thomas 09 Mar 1840 17 Sep 1862* Pvt CW Co G 9th IL Inf
  William N 12 Jan 1851 09 Jun 1906  
  Wilma J 18 Nov 1899 21 Jul 1989  
Williams John H 06 --- 1838 18 Dec 1876 (dates are hard to read)
  Louisa M 23 Oct 1835 13 Apr 1905