The first New Hope (Methodist) Cemetery was located north west of the present day cemetery. It was from land of George Haynes. In 1868 this cemetery was no longer used when land donated by J.A. Albert for the present New Hope Cemetery became available. It is noted that Penny's are buried here also.

Surname	Name	Date of Birth	Date of Death	Comments
DUTBON (?)	Mary A.	Oct. 26, 1834	Feb. 28, 1862	wife of H. Dutbon
EGEY (?)	Ludie		Aug. 1, 1872	dau. Of J. H. & S.P.. Egey, 12 yr., 3 mo.
HANNA	Ann E.	Oct. 28, 1820	Feb. 22, 1870	wife of H.E. Hanna, 49 yr.., 3 mo.. 25 da.
HANNA	Samuel		May. 14, 1857	1 day
HANNA	William S.		Oct. 24, 1855	1 yr., 1 mo., 14 da
KINCAID	Louisa		Dec. 16, 1879	46 yr., 25 da.
KINCAID	Thomas		Nov. 6, 1859
MADDOX	Eliza M.	Jan. 16, 1862	Dec. 28, 1865
MCBEE	David M.	Nov. 17, 1814	Mar. 19, 1863
MOYER	Cappie	Feb. 2, 1894	Feb. 8, 1894	dau. Of Mike Moyer
MOYER	Mike	Jun. 4, 1834	Aug. 28, 1898
NOBLE	Thos. H.		Aug. 6, 1864	59 ry., 11 mo., 7 da..
PETREE	Martha W.	Oct. 17, 1836	Oct. 1, 1866	wife of G. W. Petree
PETREE	Robert E.	May. 15, 1859	Oct. 1860	son of A.W. & M.W. Petree