
Story of History of Otero
County
Elihu Joy Led Wagon Train As told by Fay Hunter
to Clarence Adams The late 1880's were important years for a great number of pioneer spirited
Texas families. For several years they had been hearing about the many
opportunities that were to be had in the huge expanse of free land in the
Territory of New Mexico. So it is no wonder that perhaps as many as twenty-five
wagon trains of home-seekers left the Lone Star State during a period of three
or four years and headed their teams west toward the Pecos and the mountains
beyond. Leading one of the first wagon trains during that year of 1885 was Elihu Joy,
a pioneer in the truest sense, and a man who was to make much history in the
settling of the Penasco Valley of Southern New Mexico. In the same wagon train were other travelers, having much the same
aspirations as Elihu Joy, and they were people whose names are predominant over
the Sacramento Mountains today. Some of them are the Beard family, the Poseys,
Reeves, Henderson, Arthurs, Walkers, and Campbells. A couple of years later, the
Rhodes, Cox and Lee families came also, but the latter three families settled on
the West side of the mountains. Most of the families, however, settled on the
Penasco. According to several old-timers living today, another group of immigrants,
perhaps in another wagon train, also came into the valley and settled on the
lover Penasco, near where the Joy group had stopped. The location was probably
about fifteen miles below the present site of Elk. In this group were the York
family: Harrison, James, Frank, & Meredith along with Jim Dockray and Bob Keith.
The place they settled soon came to be known as "Yorktown." Later this group
began to scatter out and move to other areas throughout the mountains and the
settlement faded into oblivion. Fay Turner of Roswell, daughter of Elihu Joy, said that her mother, who was a
York, came with her father to New Mexico. "They were married before they left
Texas." She said. "When the families started scattering out, Papa and Mama moved
over into Sixteen Springs Canyon. Later they moved back to the Penasco between
Mayhill and Elk where they bought a farm and ranch and this was where I was
born. In reviewing some of the history about her family, Fay Joy Turner said
that her parents had many difficulties when coming across the Llano Estacado
(Staked Plains). "When they crossed the Pecos down near Seven Rivers, the
river was at flood stage and the folks on the wagon train were afraid to cross.
My grandpa rode across the river horseback, and the wagon train followed." she
said. She recalled that her mother had sat on the wagon seat, driving the team, while her father
had ridden one of the horses pulling the wagon. "They tied logs to each side of
the wagon so they would float better." she said. Stating that the wagon train kept moving on west until the travelers arrived
on the lower Penasco where the country appealed to them, Fay said that her
parents settled on one side of the Penasco, while her grandparents settled on
the other. "Soon the place became known as Yorktown." she said. "One time the Mescalero Indians broke out of the Reservation and came to our
place wanting food." Fay recalled. "Mama got scared and went across the creek to
my grandparents’ place until the Indians went on through." Fay said that this was not the last experience with the Mescaleros. "Indian
raids were not unusual in those days." She said. When Papa first came out here
the helped recover a herd of livestock that the Indians had driven off on one or
two occasions. He never got into a gun battle with them though. We saw Indians
from the Reservation quite often after we moved over to the Flying H. They would
come off the Reservation and ride by our place. I learned how they used the
Mescal plant to make alcohol and soap. "My parents had ten children, seven girls and three boys. The oldest one died
in about 1913 and Mama and Papa raised his children. Nancy, my mother, passed
away in 1928. Fay said that she married John Turner, who was a cowboy. "He worked for Cap
Mossman on the Turkey Track and also punched cattle on the Flying H Ranch." she
recalled. "Before my husband passed away he went to work at the oil refinery in
Artesia. Later he worked for the New Mexico Highway Department and we settled in
Roswell. But back to Fay’s father, Elihu Joy. After a long life, which had been
dominated by a pioneer spirit and a longing to tame the West, Elihu at age 72,
passed away in the country he loved so well near the head of the Felix in the
Sacramento Mountains. He was found by his son E. E. Joy, apparently the victim of a heart attack in
the corral where he had been working with a herd of calves. Even before he came to New Mexico, Elihu Joy had already experienced many
days in cattle drives as he had assisted in driving a herd of cattle over the
old Chisholm Trail across to Dodge City, Kansas. "My father also knew some of
the old-timers of the Pecos Valley such as Jim Hinkle of Roswell, and Dave
Runyan of Artesia." Fay related. Truly Elihu Joy and his family were the kind of
people that made the West the greatest place in the world to live. When Eliju Joy passed away, seven daughters and two sons survived him. The
daughters were: Mrs Ella Coe of El Paso, Mrs. Maggie Deheart of Albuquerque,
Mrs. Alma Mitchell, Mrs. John Turner of Artesia (Later of Roswell) and Mrs.
Clayton McDonald of Artesia, Mrs Winnie Potter of Hope, and Miss Nettie Joy of
Elk. The sons who survived at the time were W. R. And E. E. Joy, both of Elk.
Old Timers Review Autumn Edition 1981-82
*****************************************************************************
Lower Penasco Known as "Yorktown"
Editor’s note: In the Autumn edition of OTR we had a story about Elihu Joy, and we stated that he led the wagon train to New Mexico. Fay Joy Turner set us straight by stating that it was Elihu Joy’s father who actually led the wagon train across to New Mexico.
According to Fay Turner, her grandfather on her mother’s side, a Baptist minister whose name was York, settled south of the Penasco near the present community of Elk. "At first it was called the "York Place," she said. "But as the community grew, and when Grandpa bought the Elk Store, the place was called "Yorktown."
Fay said that her grandfather later sold the store to a Mr. Bauman, and he in turn sold the store to Bud Cleve.
"Grandpa York was better known as Uncle Bill and my grandma was called Aunt Martha." Fay said. She said that as a child growing up it was always important to her to know the past history of her people, and especially her grandparents. "I always loved to listen to my parents tell of those early days on the Penasco. I helped with the cattle and did other chores as was necessary." She said. "Most of the men in the community worked on the big C. A. Bar Ranch as ranch hands, as they had worked on in Texas before they had come to the Penasco.
Old Timers Review Winter Edition 1981-82
Retyped by Elaine Watson March 18, 2009.

Copyright © Genealogy Trails
All Rights Reserved with Full Rights Reserved for Original Contributor