The Mathias Splitlog Mission Church

Sarah Splitlog

Splitlog Family Census records


To this union ten children were born: Joseph, Henry, Thomas, and Sarah.
Still looking for the other six.


DESCRIPTION: THE MATHIAS SPLITLOG CHURCH IS AN OUTSTANDING EXAMPLE OF ROMANESQUE REVIVAL RELIGIOUS ARCHITECTURE IN OKLAHOMA. BEYOND ITS REMARKABLE ARCHITECTURE, THIS BUILDING IS A LIVING REMINDER OF THE LIFE OF MATHIAS SPLITLOG, A CAYUGA INDIAN WHO HELPED TO FOUND AND DEVELOP THE CAYUGA COMMUNITY. LISTED IN NATIONAL REGISTER 10/26/72.


Headstone reads "Mrs. Eliza Splitlog passed away at 5:10a.m. Sunday, September 28, 1894, at her home Cayuga Springs, aged 65 years.  She was the daughter of John and Hanna Barnett, Born in Sandusky, Ohio, And died in the Catholic faith."

The Mathias Splitlog Church is one of Delaware Counties Historic Places of Interest.  The story behind the man and woman who built this church, is of great interest.  They are both buried in the cemetery that is located near the church they built. This massive church was built by an Indian with his own funds.   The building is now privately owned but is well preserved and a fitting tribute to a great Indian Pioneer of Oklahoma and of Delaware County.  The church is located about nine miles northeast of Grove in Delaware County.  I have located several newspaper articles about this couple and their church as well as the history of church that the current owners have.  I will include part of their history first and include additional information found, then the articles found.
Pictured are the Saw Mill (L) and the Factory (R) that Mathias Splitlog built.

Wyandotte County, Kansas School History
On August 20, 1886, P. H. Knoblock contracted to erect another building, although the deed to the land had not yet been signed.  H. A. Curdy and husband, W. W. Curdy, deeded to the board eight lots in Block 162 of old Wyandotte on the southeast corner of Eleventh and Barnett Avenue.  Some accounts list a four-room frame built on pilings there; however, at no time were there more than three teachers at the school, even when it was most crowded.  The school was named Barnett because of its location.  The Barnetts were an early Wyandot family; one of whom married Hannah Armstrong.  Her daughter, Eliza Barnett, became the wife of Matthias Splitlog, a well-to-do Wyandot.  Splitlog Avenue was named for him, Barnett for his wife's people.  *Named Barnett because of location on Barnett Avenue, which was named for early Wyandot family (KANSAN news article). One of nine original schools. Eliza Barnett (Wyandot), married Mathias Splitlog (Canadian Mohawk), an Indian millionaire and mechanical genius who built a steamboat. The Splitlog home was between Barnett and Tauromee Avenue and 4th and 5th streets, known as "Splitlog Hill", today known as "Strawberry Hill."

Mathias Splitlog, an Indian of large business operations, lived on what then was known as "Splitlog's Hill," the house standing near the site of the great St. Mary's stone Catholic church of this day, one of the most magnificent religious edifices in the west. Splitlog was a Mohawk Indian born in Canada, but his wife was a Wyandot, a daughter of Mrs. Hannah Armstrong, who lived on the hill on the north side) of the Kansas river valley near the present city park. Splitlog was a mechanical genius. He had a mill near his house, in which he ground corn by horse power, built by himself. He afterwards erected a saw mill near where the Union Pacific Armstrong shops were built. He constructed the mill and installed the engine himself, and he was his own engineer. During the Civil war Splitlog built a small steamboat for George P. Nelson to ply the upper waters of the Missouri. It carried supplies to the Kansas sufferers while running between Wyandotte and Atchison, Nelson serving as captain and Splitlog as engineer. In 1861 the steamboat was pressed into service to carry Colonel Mulligan's soldiers down the Missouri river to Lexington. Splitlog and George Shreiner were in the boat - Splitlog as engineer and Shreiner as pilot. The boat landed in Lexington in time to be surrounded by General Price, and Shreiner lost an arm before Colonel Mulligan surrendered. Many stories are told of the remarkable shrewdness of this Indian in driving a bargain. When the Wyandot lands were divided, Splitlog took his share in the bottoms along the Kansas river. He sold his bottom lands to the railroads and they made him the wealthiest Indian in the tribe. With the Wyandots he moved to the Indian Territory, in 1874, and built a fine saw mill and grist mill. He later made investments in southwestern Missouri, platting a town there and calling it Splitlog. He also built a railroad fifty miles long running from Neosho south. Splitlog was known as the Indian millionaire and lived to be nearly ninety years old.
Transcribed from History of Wyandotte County Kansas and its people ed. and comp. by Perl W. Morgan. Chicago, The Lewis publishing company, 1911.



McDonald County, Missouri:  A wealthy Wyandotte Indian by the name of Mathias Splitlog brought development and prosperity to McDonald County for a time following the Civil War.  After selling property in Kansas City, he moved to Indian Territory where he set up a saw mill, a grist mill, store, school and fine home.  A supposed "gold strike" west of Goodman brought Splitlog to McDonald County.  He established a mine and created Splitlog City.  He then built a railroad from Joplin to Splitlog which he planned to continue all the way to the Gulf Coast.  Many couples rode that Splitlog line to spend their honeymoon at the fancy, ornature Occidental Hotel built by the millionaire Indian.  The gold mines, unfortunately, proved to be worthless.  Splitlog felt responsible for the financial losses of the many people who had relied on his advise and spent most of his remaining wealth reimbursing others.  He did not have the funds to continue the railroad and it was sold.  That little railroad begun by Mathias Splitlog is now the Kansas City Southern Railroad, one of the most important north and south rainroads in the U.S.  Splitlog made many journeys to Washington, D. C. on tribal business representing the Seneca Tribe who had "adopted" him and made him their Chief.  At age 85, Splitlog was enroute to Washington once again when he sickened.  Soon after his arrival in Washington in January 1897, he developed pneumonia and died.  His body was returned to Cayuga near Tiff City and laid to rest beside his wife.



There are many stories and legends of Mathias Splitlog the "Millionaire Indian." According to a federal land allotment report, Mathias was born in 1812 in Canada. Another report gives his birthplace as New York State. Some sources report he was a French-Canadian. Others say he was Wyandotte, and others claim he was part Cayugan. Another report was that he was stolen by Indians when a baby and reared by the Wyandottes in Ohio and at the age of fifteen was made a scout for the Indians.

Far removed were the council fires which Splitlog left when the Wyandots quit-claimed their Ohio reservation back to the United States in exchange for a home "west of the Mississippi" in 1842.  In 1843 Splitlog, along with about eight hundred members of the Ohio Wyandotte tribe, migrated to Kansas; a movement as harsh as the more publicized "Trail of Tears". The Wyandottes were assigned a tract of 148,110 acres on the Neosho River. This proved to be unsuitable for the tribe so they purchased thirty-nine sections of land from the Delawares. The new holdings, located in the fork of the Missouri and the Kansas Rivers, encompassed the present location of Kansas City, Kansas.

Mathias married Eliza Charloe Barnett, a great-niece of Chief Jacques. He later built a log home on a small hill overlooking his land along the Kansas (present name is Kaw) river bottoms. After he and his family were settled, he built a grist mill, and later he built a saw mill. Both mills were run by a steam engine.

For a man without education Mathias was a mechanical genius. He could study a piece a machinery and soon build an exact replica. In 1860, using new principles he had reasoned out, Splitlog constructed a steamboat to ply the Missouri river, carrying freight to the small settlements along the water, highway. It had an engine of tremendous power; however, no one but Mathias could operate it. Then the area was gripped in the frenzy of the Civil War and Mathias became a soldier in the Union Army as a "Soldier of the Cannon" under Colonel Mulligan. Mathias was an engineer on this boat, and while they were transporting a regiment to the battle area, it was captured near Lexington, Missouri. A court martial was held and Mathias was paroled and he walked all the way back to his home.

In September 1863, the Union Pacific Railroad crossed the Kansas river near Splitlog's sawmill and lumber yard. Splitlog was spellbound by the railroad work and especially by the excavating machine that could do the work of a hundred men. Not even the steamboats had fascinated Mathias like the first locomotive he saw. It was a love that he never relinquished and had a bearing on his later life. With his land located as it was, Mathias began to amass his great fortune with the Union Pacific paying a fabulous sum for the right-of-way and several acres on which to locate railroad shops.

Always cautious and suspicious in his dealings with the white man, Mathias began swinging some shrewd land deals, The largest part of his allotment on the hill, still referred to as "Splitlog Hill," he sold to a syndicate that plotted early Kansas City, Kansas. These land sales created international recognition and he was known as the "Millionaire Indian."

By 1855 the white men realized that the Indians were living on some of most valuable land in the area. Then began again the familiar story of agitation for Indian removal. By 1857 most of the Wyandottes had either sold or lost their Kansas holdings so they were homeless. It was at time that the Seneca tribe paid an age-old debt to the Wyandottes by giving them 30,000 acres of land across the north end of the Seneca reservation in Indian Territory. In 1874 Mathias sold the remainder of his holdings in Kansas and moved his family to Indian Territory. He chose as his home an area near the Cowskin and the Grand Rivers. There was a large spring on his land which he named "Cayuga" in honor of his wife who was a member of the Cayuga tribe.

The Cayuga tribe meeting grounds are located north of the Elk River area of Grand Lake. Sitting on the bank of the lake in a grove of virgin oak timber, the location is ideal for their monthly council meetings and yearly ceremonial dances. These dances annually draw well over 2,000 people during the week long festival.

One of the first enterprises established by the Splitlog in Indian Territory was the installation of a sawmill. He also built a grist mill. He put in a ferry and built a general store. Mathias built a fine home which was embellished with cupolas and, as was the style of the era, a plentiful amount of architectural "gingerbread." He also built a well equipped blacksmith shop. There no schools so Splitlog organized a subscription school, furnished a building, and allowed the teacher to retain all that she collected.

After the other businesses were in successful operation, Splitlog started construction of a large factory which, when completed, contained three stories and a basement. Here he began the manufacture of wagons, buggies and two-seated hacks. All of the wooden parts for the vehicles came from Splitlog's own sawmill. This factory also made coffins from well-seasoned walnut. When there was a death in the community all other work at the factory ceased while a coffin was being built.

The post office of Cayuga Springs was established in June 1894 with Joseph Splitlog, one of Mathias sons, as the first postmaster. It was about this time that the far-seeing Splitlog discerned that the days of the hack and the horse were numbered, and that if Cayuga were to continue to develop it must have a railroad. Enlisting the aid of friends and pouring his own wealth and energy the project.

Splitlog promoted the three-million-dollar "Splitlog Line" from Joplin, Missouri to Neosho, Missouri, thence to Splitlog City. On August 15, 1887 the road was completed to Neosho, Missouri and a silver spike celebration was held, Then on June 30, 1869 another celebration was held, this time at Splitlog City, the new end of the track. After it was completed to Splitlog City, there were many couples who rode the Splitlog line from Joplin to Splitlog City to spend their honeymoon at the fancy, ornate Occidental Hotel built by the millionaire Indian.

Legend tells that Splitlog paid his payroll in gold. The gold was transported from Cayuga Springs in a wagon driven by Chief Splitlog and guarded by his heavily armed sons.

It was about this time that Splitlog was swindled in a fake gold mining scheme. Clay, a director of the railroad came to Splitlog with a story of the strike in McDonald County, Missouri. Splitlog purchased forty acres where the strike was made, plus many acres surrounding the farm.

Splitlog Land and Mining Company was formed and leases upon five thousand acres of land. On the road and trails leading to Splitlog City were seen white canvas-topped wagons with Bound for Splitlog" painted on their sides. It wasn't long until everyone was aware the entire mining venture was a hoax and that the mine had been salted with "Fool's Gold." M.C. Clay left the country and as a last gesture of honest effort to set things right, Splitlog sacrificed other property and paid off in cash the losses suffered by innocent persons. This display of generosity almost broke him.

Mathias Splitlog was adopted into the Seneca tribe in 1890. He was elected Chief of the Senecas. The day of the election he gave a feast for his friends and fellow tribesmen. Fifteen hundred loaves of bread were hauled from the bakery at Southwest City. Three beefs were prepared to feed the multitude. The Indian band, which was outfitted and sponsored by Splitlog, lent a festive air to the occasion.

In 1892 the railroad had been extended to Sulphur Springs, Arkansas. Arthur E. Stilwell started dickering for the Splitlog Line. Finally the hard-pressed owners sold for the fabulously low price of $50,000.00. Age was beginning to tell on Mathias Splitlog and he had already lost twice that much on the line.

Although not as devout a Catholic as his wife, Splitlog became more interested in religion as the years rolled by. So in 1886 he began plans for a church to be built south of the factory. Constructed a hewn limestone from the area, the inside was embellished with beautifully hand-carved imported wood. Starting at the right front window and proceeding in a counter-clockwise route, the name "Splitlog" is spelled out, one letter over each arched stained-glass window. The arch forming the doorway is formed of fifteen stones, each of which is carved with an Indian symbol.

When Eliza Splitlog died in 1894, the church was still unfinished but her funeral was held in the partially completed building. Work continued on the church with several interruptions when Splitlog had to journey to Washington, D.C. on tribal business. It was practically completed on November 25, 1896 when it was dedicated. It was blessed by Bishop Meerschaert and by Father Ketcham. The bronze bell, which had been cast in Belgium, first tolled on memory of Eliza Splitlog during the dedication. This is the only church in Oklahoma and perhaps in the United States which was built solely by an Indian from his own funds for the religious use of all people.

Splitlog was now eighty-five years of age and the shadows of his life were growing longer and longer. It was on December 22, 1896, the Splitlog again started a journey to Washington on behalf of his adopted people. On the way, he sickened and soon after he arrived in the capital city, he developed pneumonia and died soon thereafter. His body was returned to Cayuga where Requiem Mass was said on January 14, 1897 in the church the old man had dreamed, financed and built.

Mathias Splitlog was buried beside his wife a few hundred feet from the Cayuga Mission. Almost single-handedly Splitlog had hammered a wilderness into a progressive, civilized way of life. Today the old church bell still rings. It calls the faithful to worship every Sunday morning at 8:30am. Loud and clear, its clarion peals over the streams and valleys of what was once the Seneca Nation.

More recently, the church was purchased from the Methodist church by a private individual in 1949. He did major repairs on the building and received the original bell from a church in Nowata, Oklahoma. The pews and alter in the front of the church were purchased from a Catholic church in the early 1950's. The pews in the balcony are the original ones.

The Lord's Supper painting on the front of the alter was very faded when first purchased, so it was removed and repainted by an artist related to the private individual. The church has now changed ownership from the private owner to his son who has done additional restorations. Because of the blessings of God, the church is now a full-time place of worship for many today.

Publication: The Oklahoman Date: Feb. 20, 1972 Page 138 by Kent Ruth
Church Recalls Great Indian
Splitlog Church- some nine miles northeast of Grove in Delaware County is a handsome, still impressive monument to a remarkabley able, public-spirited man.  Mathias Splitlog was born in New York in 1812, half Cayugan, half French by ancestry.  An important figure on four frontiers, he died in 1897.  With his wife Eliza, a Wyandot, he lies buried in the pleasant oak-shaded burying ground of the church he helped dedicate just six weeks before he died.  The Church itself may well be the only structure of its kind in the country today, built by an Indian with his own funds.  Splitlog "possessed the quality known as vision," according to one historian.  "His ideas were ahead of his time," another noted.  "He was always planning and building."  Pressured from homes in Ohio, Kansa and Missouri, the Wyandots finally found a sanctuary, in 1874, among the Senecas here in Indian Territory.  Once again Splitlog set to work building a new life for his people.  He settled near a spring he name Cayuga.  The town that sprang up around it became Cayuga Springs.  He built a sawmill (see picture above) and a grist mill, established a blacksmith shop, operated a ferry--and erected an impressive 4-story factory (see picture above) for manufacturing watons and buggies.  Most ambitious of his projects, however (if largely unsuccessful) was the Splitlog Line, now part of the Kansas City Southern Lines.  Work began on it in 1887.  By 1889 the tracks had reached Splitlog City, in nearby Missouri.  "I go on," he promised in a dedicatory speech, "I make Cuyuga and Splitlog biggest towns in the Ozarks."  Alas, Splitlog Church is about all that's left today of the Cayuga Springs settlement.  But is is no crude fronties affair.  Matchings its buttressed walls and high roof, topped by towers front and back, were ornately carved altar, confessionsal and choir loft, stained glass windows, and a bell cast in Belgium.  The organ had not been delivered when Splitlog died.  But the rock ruin behind the church once housed a steam heating plant.  "The special Catholic furnishings were removed when the church was sold to the Methodists in 1930.  Though privately owned today, Splitlog Church is well preserved, an altogether fitting tribute to a great man.
Publication: The Oklahoman Date: Nov. 29, 1981 Page 9 by Don Hayden
Church Lone Reminder of Grove Pioneer
Grove- Mathias Splitlog was never a man to let grass grow under his feet, but 84 years after his death, grass is about all that remains of a town he founded in northeastern Oklahoma.  An impressive gray stone church with a white wooden steeple still stands as a reminder of Splitlog's era.  Completed in 1897 only six weeks before Splitlog died, the church was used for Catholic services until 1930, when it was sold to Methodists.  Today, the church is used in the summertime for interdenominational services and an occasional reunion of area residents.  Listed in the National Register of Historical Places, the church is located about nine miles northeast of Grove.  Splitlog, of French and Cayuga Indian ancestry, was born in New York in 1912.  He moved westward in the early 1880s and settled near a river he named Cayuga.  He went on to develop a town near the site, chich he called Cayuga Springs.  Area historians say he always had some project going, noting the man built a sawmill, a grist mill, operated a ferry, opened a blacksmith shop and built a four-story factory where wagons and buggies were made.  In 1887, he gan working on a railroad which he called the "Splitlog Line" which later became part of the Kansas City Southern Line.  He claimed he would make Cayuga Springs the "biggest town in the Ozarks."  Although that never happened, it didn't stop Splitlog, who continued planning and building.  The church, built with Splitlogis own funds, is no crude affair with its buttressed walls and high peaked roof.  A tower in the rear of the building matches the steeple.  Inside the church is a hand-carved alter transported from England, stained glass windows and a bell make in Belgium.  The congregation was warmed with steam heat, but all that remains of the plant is a rocky ruin behind the church.
Excerpt from Publication: The Oklahoman Date: Jun. 26, 1988 Page 84 on Ghost Towns

Cayuga is our No. 2 ghost.  It dozes on the south bank of Grand Lake's Cowkin area- that's five-plus miles east of Grove (on Oklahoma 25), then three miles north.  It comes within little more that one extant structure falling to No. 1 status.  But Splitlog Church is no ordinary structure.  Nor was Mathias Splitlog your ordinary church builder.  Unable to read or write, he's said to have spoken seven languages.  And, along with the useful ability to make money, he possessed what one observer has called "the quality known as vision."  What with "a mechanical and inventive turn of mind," he seems almost predestined to be an overachiever on the raw frontier.  His church was obviously no fly-by-night operation.  Built of native sandstone, approximately 20 X 50 feet in size with a high sharply pitched roof, it boasted a tall bell tower and steeple.  Yet it was not only the last of a series of notable structures that thrust him into the front ranks of Indian entrepreners who helped develop Indian Territory.  Mathias Splitlog was born in New York in 1812 - by ancestry half Cayugan and half French.  As a young man in Ohio, he married Eliza Barnett, thus becoming a member of the Wyandot tribe.  As ever increasing white pressure pushed the Indians westward he followed them, first in Kansas and then to northeast Oklahoma.  A final move in 1874 put the now 62 year old leader on the Cowskin near its mouth in the Neosho (Grand) River.  There he put to work with that quality known as vision, the $170,000 he had reportedly received for his holdings in Kansas.  (Wyandot land there was in present Kansas City and before the move Splitlog had built a solid reputation as flour miller, builder, and real estate dealer.)  His vision was for a self-contained community that could presumably support inself and thus be able to resist more forced moves.  He named it Cayuga for his own tribe.  He built a sawmill and gristmill-established a store, blacksmith shop, and ferry service on the Cowskin-erected an impressive three-story and basement factory to produce wagons and buggies.  He also started a subscription school.  By 1887, he was ready for his more ambitious project: the "Splitlog Line", his own railroad to tie the production of his factory to the markets of the world.  Forerunner of a section of the present Kansas City Southern Lines, the Splitlog reached Splitlog City (in hearby Missouri) in 1889.  "I go on," Splitlog promised in a celebration speech, "I make Cayuga and Splitlog biggest towns in the Ozarks."  Alas his dream was never fulfilled.  Today, mills and factory are gone and Cayuga is but a public access point on the Grand Lake recreation map.  Only Splitlog Church remains.  The interesting old oak-shaded burying ground is just to the south.  It is not known just when Splitlog fir became interested in building a church.  Although a baptized Roman Catholic, he had never shown and particular interest in religion until Father William Ketcham came to Indian Territory in 18892.  The following year, Splitlog was confirmed-and began work on his church.  Eliza Splitlog, a devout Quaker upt o that time, converted to Catholicism.  She died in 1894 and was buried from the still-uncompleted structure.  Not until later 1896 was the church finally finished.  Atr the dedicatory service the bell, specially cast in Belgium, was blessed and first tolled in her memory.  An interesting feature of the church, the front doorway arch contains 15 stones carved with Indian symbols.  Rarely used today the curch and its well-tended, still open cemetery now doze quietly amid large protective oaks.  New tombstones are scattered among the weathered ones--some ornate marble ones--lie those of Eliza and Mathias Splitlog--others worn fieldstones on which nothing can now be read.
Excerpt from Publication: The Oklahoman Date: Sep. 9, 2000 By Sheila Stogsdll

Church near Grand Lake built for all

For wealthy Indian couple, project was labor of love
----
Grove--Nestled near Elk River and Grand Lake, amid acres of lush folliage, tourists to the area are often surprised to find a century-old stone church among the lake cabins and boats.  The gray limestone church is set on top of a hill, overlooking the coves with a stepple tall enought it can be seen almost a mile away.  The old stone church and its picturesque cemetery is called Cayuga Splitlog Mission Church.  Visitors walking among the cemetery's mid-1880 grave markers may see a doe and her fawn grazing nearby or a mischievous raccoon stealing a flower off a grave.  Cayuga Splitlog Mission Church was built by Mathias and Eliza Splitlog.  It is considered to be the only church in Oklahoma, and perhaps in the United States, that was built solely by an Indian from his own funds for the religious use of all people.  Mathias Splitlog, also known as the "Millionaire Indian," built the church out of love for his wife.  But the church became a symbol of love between Mathias and his Creator as well.  Little is know of Splitlog's early life.  Accourding to federal land allotment papers he was born in 1812 in Canada.  Other reports place his birthplace as New York state or list Splitlog as a French Canadiand and Cayuga Indian descendant; other claims say Splitlog was part Wyandotte and part Cayuga Indian.  Another report states he was stolen by the Indians as a baby and reared by the Wyandotte Tribe in Ohio.  Variations of the story add that at age 15, he was scout, or that when he married Eliza Barnett, great-niece of Jacques of the Wyandotte Tribe, he became a member.  What is known is that Splitlog never received any formal schooling, nor did he learn to read or write.  The lack of schooling did not prevent him for excelling.  Gifted with a bright mind, Splitlog would often watch and study the steam engine and soon mastered its principles.  By studying the machinery, he could soon built a replica that powered a boat he and his brother built as they engaged in trade in the Great Lakes area.  By 1843, Splitlog and his wife, along with 800 members of the Ohio Wyandotte Tribe, migrated to Kansas.  The tribe had been assigned a tract of nearly 150,000 acres on the Neosho River.  The land proved to be unsuitable, so the tribe bought 30 sections of land from the Delaware Indians.  The new holding, in the fork of the Missouri and Kansas rivers, is now the site of Kansas City, Kansas.  Always the entrepreneur, Splitlog built a sawmill, gristmill and another steamboat that journeyed on the Missouri River, eventually making Splitlog a wealthy man.  By 1874, political pressure forced the Splitlogs to move to Indian Territory, where they were welcomed by the Seneca-Cayugas.  The Splitlogs built a sawmill, a buggy factory and a general store.  Not known as a religious man, Splitlog would often allow his general store to serve as a church Sunday mornings.  Father Ketchum, a Roman Catholic priest, converted the Splitlogs to Catholicism and in 1886 Splitlog began plans for a church to be built south of the buggy factory.  Ketchum helped design the church and used limestone that was plentiful in the area.  The church was decorated inside with hand-carved, imported wood.  At the front of the church is an elaborate carved piano, which sits silent due to years of abandonment.  Outside, the name "Splitlog" is spelled out, on letter over each arched, stained glass window.  The arch forming the doorway to the church is formed with fifteen stones, each carved with an Indian symbol.  Eliza Splitlog died in 1894, and her funeral was held in the unfinished church, with her final resting place on the grounds near the church.  Work continued on the church with several interruptions as Splitlog traveled to Washington, D. C., on Indian business.  The church was completed and dedicated October 25, 1896.  Included in the dedication ceremony was a tribute to Eliza Splitlog that included the ringing of a bronze bell.  On Dec. 22, 1896, Splitlog began what would be his final journey to Washington, D.C., on behalf of the Seneca Tribe.  While en route, he fell ill, and soon after his arrival in Washington, he developed pheumonia and died.  His body was returned to Cayuga, where Mass was celebrated Jan 14, 1897 in the same stone church that he and Eliza had built.  He was buried in the cemetery that adjoings the church.  For many years, the church was unused.  Later, the church served as a school, then was abandoned and fell prey to vandalism.  The bronze bell that had been cast in Belgium and once summoned its congregation to the old stone church was transferred to St. Catherine's parish in Nowata but later returned to Cayuga Splitlog Mission Church.  The old tarnished bell now is in the front yard of the church's groundskeeper.  The Catholic diocese sold the building to the Methodist Church in the early 1930's.  It was later sold to R.A. Sellers Sr., whose family owns a lake home near the church.  The Sellers family has repaired the church throughout the years and has made provisions for care of the church and adjoining cemetery.  For many years, bells rang out over Grand Lake, as a group forming the Grand Lake Ministries began to hold services from May until September for tourists.  In 1998, the group disbanded; however, several residents from the area met with the Sellers family, and with the family's blessing, Cayuga Mission church was opened year round.  In 1998, a 6-foot mural was discovered in a room behind the alter.  The mural depicts what Delaware County would have been like at the turn of the 20th century.  Much is unknown about the hisotry of the painting.  Victoria L. Morell, most likely the name of the artist, and the date 1946 is painted on the far right side of the mural.
 

Mathias Splitlog Leaves His Mark
on the Oklahoma Landscape

November 27, 2002 The Oklahoma Audio Almanac
The Mathias Splitlog Church in Delaware County sits today on the shores of Grand Lake and has faithfully served the surrounding communities for more than 145 years. Mathias Splitlog moved from northern Kansas to Missouri and then into the Seneca Nation in what is now Oklahoma. Splitlog, a member of the Cayuga Tribe was born in either 1810 or 1812 on the Canadian border. He married Eliza Carloe, a Wyandot, and moved with that tribe to northeast Kansas. The land held by Eliza and Mathias eventually became what is now down town Kansas City, and it was through the sale of the much sought after real estate in 1865 that Mathias became known at the time as "The Millionaire Indian." Following the sale of the Kansas land, the family moved south into the northeastern corner of present day Oklahoma. There Mathias and his wife financed the construction of several mills, a railroad, various businesses and what eventually became the town of Cayuga Springs. In 1886 Mathias began the project for which he is most remembered, the construction of the Splitlog Church. Mathias intended the church as a present for his wife. Constructed out of hewn limestone the church sits tall and narrow with a magnificent steeple. The interior of the building features imported hand carved wood, and the fifteen stone arch at the entrance displays Native American art work around the edge. A bronze bell cast in Belgium finished off the church ringing for the first time during the funeral service of Eliza Splitlog, who died during the construction of her church. It was in this week of 1896, ten years after beginning, that Mathias Splitlog oversaw the completion and dedication of his church. The bronze bell still rings, and the Cayuga Mission Church, with the Splitlog graves beside it, still holds services today, more than one hundred and forty years after its official opening.
Excerpt from Publication: The Oklahoman Date:Apr. 15, 2007 Page 55 by Allison Roberts
Sites Reflect forgotten History
Markers Identify ghost towns started by settlers within state.

Some of Oklahoma's ghost towns stand as a testament to the determination of the people that founded them.  Cayuga, a settlement in the northeastern corner of Delaware County, was planted by American Indian Mathias Splitlog.  Upon settling Cayuga in the early 1890's, Splitlog built a wagon factory, a genearal store and a blacksmith shop to promote town commerce.  Splitlog was also responsible for the construction of a Gothic-style Catholic church in 1896.  Atop the belfry was a 1,600 pound bell that reportedly could be heard 12 miles away.  Despite Splitlog's dedication to Cayuga, the town faltered following a fire that consumed much of the community.  The church, however, was spared from damage and remains a reminder of one individual's effect on Oklahoma's history.  In 1972, the Cayuga Splitlog Church was added to the Nations Register of Historical Places.


Back

Cayuga Cemetery